KRIZA VLADAVINE PRAVA U SVETLU „NUŽNOSTI” ZAŠTITE NACIONALNOG (USTAVNOG) IDENTITETA
Abstract
The creation of a European identity through respect for the values of the national system is simultaneously accompanied by a weakening of the (European) rule of law. It was believed that countries close to the European Union share the same values as it, that is, that their common values represent a guarantee of stability. However, it turned out to be the opposite. The desire of the European Union to contribute to the progress of the region through the policy of conditionality encountered the obstacle of protecting the principle of national (constitutional) identity on the part of the member states (Hungary and Poland), which gave the outlines of the beginning of the rule of law crisis with such an approach. While the first part of the work will be devoted to the theoretical and practical importance of national (constitutional) identity and the rule of law through the construction of European Union politics, both internal and external, the second part will be based on Hungary and Poland and their criminal slippages from the core of all the values of the European Union – the rule of law.
References
Cvetković, Aleksandar. 2021. Uticaji istorijskih ustava Srbije i Jugoslavije na izgradnju nacionalnog ustavnog identiteta. Beograd: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Fabbrini, Federico, Sajó, András. 4/2019. The dangers of constitutional identity. European Law Journal 25: 457–473.
Faraguna, Pietro. 7/2017. Constitutional Identity in the Age of Global Migration: Constitutional Identity in the EU – A Shield or a Sword? German Law Journal 18: 1617–1640.
Halmai, Gábor. 1/2018. Abuse of Constitutional Identity – The Hungarian Constitutional Court on Interpretation of Article E) (2) of the Fundamental Law. Review of Central and East European law 43: 23–42.
Jovanović Miloš. 2021. Pojam „evropskih vrednosti”: između snažne pro- klamacije i suštinske neodređenosti. Evropsko zakonodavstvo 76: 5–31
Jovanović, Miodrag, Dajović, Goran, Vasić, Radmila. 2019. Uvod u pravo. Beograd: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Jovanović, Miodrag. 2011. O ustavnom identitetu – slučaj Srbije. Konsti- tucionalizam i vladavina prava u izgradnji nacionalne države – slučaj Sr- bije. Beograd: Fakultet političkih nauka – Pravni fakultet Univeziteta u Beogradu: 9–31.
Lukić Radović Maja, Vlajković, Marija. 12/2019. Kriza vrednosti u Evrop- skoj uniji – uzdrmani temelji. Pravni život: 407–422.
Marinković, Tanasije. 2020. Ustavni identitet vidovdanske Jugoslavije. Sto godina od ujedinjenja – formiranje države i prava (ur. Boris Begović). Beo- grad: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu: 95–121.
Martí, José Luis. 2013. Two Different Ideas of Constitutional Identity: Identity of the Constitution v. Identity of the People. In Alejandro Sáiz Arnáiz, Carina Alcoberro (eds.), National Constitutional Identity and European Integration. Antwerp: Intersentia 17–36.
Petrov, Vladan, Stanković, Marko. 2020. Ustavno pravo. Beograd: Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Polzin, Monika. 7/2017. Articles Special Issue Constitutional Identity in the Age of Global Migration – Constitutional Identity as a Constructed Reality and a Restless Soul. German Law Journal 18: 1595–1616.
Tošić, Jovana. 2021. Sud pravde Evropske unije kao poslednja nada za su- novrat vladavine prava u Poljskoj – poseban osvrt na pravosudnu refor- mu. Evropsko zakonodavstvo 75: 73–89.
Vlajković, Marija. 2018. Razvoj načela zaštite nacionalnog identiteta u pravnom poretku Evropske unije. Evropsko zakonodavstvo 66: 47–69.
Vlajković, Marija. 2020. Rule of law – Eu’s common constitutional “denominator” and a crucial membership condition on the changed and evolutionary role of the rule of law value in the Eu context. Eu and comparative law issues and challenges series (ECLIC): 235–257.
Vlajković, Marija. 2020. Uslovljavanje u spoljnoj politici Evropske unije: izazovi pravno-političkog „izvoza” vrednosti u susedstvo. Identitetski preobražaj Srbije. Beograd: Udruženje za međunarodno krivično pravo – Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu: 313–323.
Ko je ovde suveren?, http://mons.rs/ko-je-ovde-suveren, poslednji pristup 25. oktobar2022.
A New Page in Protecting European Constitutional Values: How to best use the new EU Rule of Law Framework vis-a-vis Poland, https://verfas-sungsblog.de/a-new-page-in-protecting-european-constitutional-values- how-to-best-use-the-new-eu-rule-of-law-framework-vis-a-vis-poland/, poslednji pristup 5. novembar 2022.
Constitutional Identity in and on EU Terms, https://verfassungsblog.de/constitutional-identity-in-and-on-eu-terms/, poslednji pristup 5. februara 2023.
Hungary, Poland and the “Community of Fate”, https://verfassungsblog.de/ hungary-poland-and-the-community-of-fate/, poslednji pristup 3. novem- bra 2022.
Mađarska i Evropska unija: Rezolucija Evropskog parlamenta – prome- nite LGBT zakon ili idemo na sud i nema novca, https://www.bbc.com/ serbian/lat/svet-57607599, poslednji pristup 3. novembra 2022.
Problematising the ‘rule of law’ as a concept, https://www.clingendael.org/pub/2017/a_shotgun_marriage/1_problematising_the_rulr_of_law_as_a_ concept/, poslednji pristup 7. novembra 2022.
Rule of Law and Democracy: Addressing the Gap Between Policies and Practices, https://www.un.org/en/chronicle/article/rule-law-and-democ-racy-addressing-gap-between-policies-and-practices, poslednji pristup 29. aprila 2023.
